After the “2007 – A Look Back” post, I thought that I’d have one final post this year that would simply look forward with some optimism toward 2008. However, there’s been such activity in the comments with accusations and threats leveled against this blog that there were a few things that needed to be addressed.

Now we are getting a better idea of why some were so riled up in the past few days since my “Burning down the Village” post came out…

Carpentersville Trustees Paul Humpfer and Judy Sigwalt convene with members of the Fox Valley Citizens for Legal Immigration on Fridays before board meetings to go over the upcoming village board agendas.

The two trustees acknowledged the meetings, while attempting to downplay the significance (of course!). However, there appears to be admittance that they met with this group using their Board packets.

[Village President] Sarto and [Village Manager] Anderson said confidential material could land in the wrong hands since material regarding items discussed in executive session often are included in board packets.

They claim they didn’t plan out comments ahead of time. But … what about the following from September 5, 2006:

Michael Williams, 36 Elm Avenue; a resident who expressed concern over the manner in which this Board is addressing the issue of illegal immigration. President Sarto cautioned Mr. Williams that the Board has enacted Rules of Decorum and noted that only items relating to Village business are deemed to be appropriate to discuss under Public Comment. While Mr. Williams believes he has every right to discuss this at this time, President Sarto stated there are other channels for Mr. Williams to express his opinion. Discussion ensued regarding immigration laws and to what extent does federal, state and local governments have the ability to address this. Mr. Williams continued to state his right to express his opinion over this issue. Because Mr. Williams addressed Trustee Ramirez Sliwinski directly, President Sarto asked Mr. Williams to end his discussion. Many comments came forth from the audience and President Sarto subsequently requested certain people to leave the Board Room.

In video of the interaction, as Mr. Williams reads his statement before the Board and President Sarto explains why his comments do not meet the criteria for Village business, Trustees Humpfer and Sigwalt appear all too ready to jump in, in a scene that seems highly suspect:

They proceed to dismiss Sarto’s ruling … although without a vote. In later meetings however, on at least 3 occasions to my recollection, the ruling of the President is appealed, voted on and the person is allowed to continue comments that are outside the bounds of the Rules of Decorum and the express purpose of Village Board meetings, as set forth in the Municipal Code.

Here is one such incident from July 17, 2007, where the head of Fox Valley Citizens for Legal Immigration (FVCFLI), Bob Sperlazzo, comes before the Board to talk about illegal immigration. When President Sarto attempts to stop his comments for indecorum and explains that the Board has voted to not discuss the issue, and after Mr. Sperlazzo is unsuccessful in arguing his point that his comments should be allowed, he appears to make a gesture and look in the direction of Trustees Humpfer and Sigwalt. Trustee Humpfer then immediately calls to “appeal the ruling of the President”, and Trustee Sigwalt immediately seconds it.

These two incidents alone are evidence of a much more serious issue which I am glad that the Village Manager and Village Attorney are intending to look into. Something to consider is that, while it takes 3 trustees to make a quorum, it only takes two to bring an actionable item to the whole Board — as we saw in the above videos.

Another recent example occurred earlier this month, at the December 4th meeting, when the ruling of the President was again appealed (twice!) to allow Bob Sperlazzo and another member, Jay Radke, to speak about a matter that the Village Attorney also concurred did not fall under the criteria of Village business.

I encourage everyone to email the Village Board expressing your outrage at the behavior of these trustees. Or, do it during public comments at Wednesday’s Village Board meeting. Folks, these aren’t “lies” and “innuendos” as some have tried to paint them. This is evidence of the kinds of behavior that this blog has been reporting on for several months — part of a calculated effort to undermine and impugn the credibility of President Sarto, as well as manipulate and interfere with the business of the Village of Carpentersville.

Are you going to accept that?